Skip to main content

I Evaluated My Sitting MLA Through A Bunch of RTIs And He Failed

As the elections draw closer, we get multiple calls from political enthusiasts to check the background of each candidate contesting in our constituency and cast our vote for the deserving candidate rather than our favourite party. There are multiple apps available to ‘know our candidate’ at the snap of a button, which compile the data available in the affidavits submitted by the candidates to the election commission. While this is extremely useful to evaluate the candidates, one step forward would be to evaluate our sitting MLAs for their actual performance. Here, such an attempt has been made to evaluate the performance of my MLA of the infamous Dr. Radhakrishnan Nagar constituency, Mr. TTV. Dinakaran.

We may all remember RK nagar and TTV. Dinakaran for one of the most interesting political episodes that followed after the demise of the CM Jayalalitha. First, he contested under AIADMK banner in the by-election that was called off by ECI for cash-for-vote scam and the next election where he contested as an independent under the notorious pressure-cooker symbol. He was alleged for having scammed the voters by disbursing 20Rs. Notes as token for a greater sum of money that will be issued after elections once the poll watchdog relaxes its stringent watch. However, it never happened and TTV stayed away from the constituency for the rest of his tenure. Currently, he is contesting from Kovilpatti, smartly avoiding RK nagar. His innovative formula to win Kovilpatti may come out only after the election.

Evaluating TTV. Dinakaran’s term in RK Nagar:

Through a set of RTIs, the following information were demanded from concerned government departments;

·       His attendance in the legislative assembly

·       List of questions he has raised in the assembly and the debates he took part

·       Standing committees he is part of in the assembly.

·       Welfare schemes he has proposed in the constituency from his MLACDS fund and its status

Other than this, his affidavit submitted to the ECI was accessed from the ECI website to check his criminal record and educational qualification.

MLA’s background check:

His affidavit says he has 7 criminal cases against him and his educational qualification is plus two. Also, he is a dropout from civil engineering degree. He has total self-declared assets over 11 crore rupees.

MLA’s performance in the assembly:

As far as his attendance in the assembly is concerned, the TN assembly rejects disclosing any details of MLA’s attendance as a breach of privilege. So, this data cannot be sought. It must be noted that such attendance details are available for LS & RS members in the government website itself. States like Karnataka too have furnished such details in their official website. There is a long way to go for Tamil Nadu to implement such measures, where the lawmakers are still not ready to live telecast assembly proceedings to the people.

Since Mr. MLA took charge there has been 6 assembly sessions, in which he has not raised a single question in the assembly either for the people or for the constituency. He has never utilised the question hours even remotely productive and he scores a duck in that as per RTI answer from the assembly.

However, he has took part in a few debates. 5 times to be exact. The details of which are available in www.assembly.tn.gov.in. In these 5 times, he has not spoken anything remarkable too, one was after the Tuticorin Sterlite incident and the other times where he was just indulging in petty exchanges with his former colleagues turned rivals of the AIADMK faction. His assembly performance too is close to nothing.

Out of the 12 standing committees of the house, he is part of only one, which is Papers laid on the table of the house.

Welfare schemes to the constituency through MLACDS funds:

Each MLA is assigned to the tune of Rs. 3 crores per year as MLACDS fund. An RTI filed to the collectorate on the details of how these funds are appropriated in the constituency was sent back and forth to various departments among themselves for 3 long months before Chennai corporation finally furnished the details.

The RTI reveal says he has sanctioned up to 8.94 crore Rupees from financial year 2017-18 to 2020-21. Most of which are infrastructure development in government schools and anganwadis, noon-meal centres, laying concrete roads and so on including a sanction for equipping his so called ‘office’ in the constituency with computers.

The MLACDS funds are however not an effective measure for evaluation since all the MLAs get the prescribed amount and are diverted to the concerned local bodies from where funds are allocated to multiple departments.

TTV Dinakaran’s marksheet:

MLA Background (education & criminal cases): 5/20

MLA Performance in assembly: 7/50

MLACDS funds: 18/30

Total – 30/100 [FAIL]

A comprehensive evaluation of all sitting MLAs and ranking them shall prove to be wielding more power to the public, making the legislators accountable for their performance. When every employee sits through a process of evaluation every year, why should our elected representatives be exempted?


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Thoughts while stirring the kesari on my mom's birthday!

 One of the best books I have read is “My Father Baliah.” Baliah’s son narrates how his father raised his family through education. It is a simple book on the legacy of a father and the ordinary things our parents do that shape our lives and the people we become. I remember reading the last chapter of the book on my Kindle while on a train. The book ends with Baliah being taken to the grave, and I cried thinking about my mom. I thought to myself that someday I should write a book titled “My Mother Tamilselvi.” The thoughts reappeared when I was cooking kesari on my mom’s birthday. That is the only dish she would consistently prepare for all our birthdays. We used to tease her that she couldn't cook anything else, and she never bothered to prove us wrong. Though I may not be close to writing a book, I thought of writing down the thoughts running through my mind while stirring the kesari. People usually credit mothers for delicious meals, but to be honest, I do not remember any of he...
Post a Comment
Read more

Mrs. America Settles The Aged Question Of Why It Is Absolutely Normal That Women Fight Each Other, But, Throws New Questions To Today’s Women.

Ever since mankind was born, men were at each other’s throats; invaded territories; indulged in wars that ripped the world into fragments; divided humans based on superficial hierarchies like race, sex, caste, etc.,; did not even spare splitting families over property disputes and others, yet, we never dare to label them as “men being men’s best enemies.” But, one woman talks against a woman, the society goes great lengths to ascertain that women hate each other. As Gloria Steinem says in the recent Disney + Hotstar miniseries, Mrs. America , “They have found the perfect smokescreen to hide their chauvinism-women.” It is true that women need to fight together to uproot patriarchy. But the unfair obligation to always be nice to each other, is yet another unreasonable expectation shoved down our throats. Mrs. America settles this once and for all, of how normal it is for women to dissent. After all, feminism has never been ONE supreme way of achieving equality. There are inroads that ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Gunjan Saxena: A Sincere Storytelling That Stays Focused Just On The Girl And Her Dreams

Anna Vetticad says in her review of Gunjan Saxena, that it is a story of one remarkable woman, but also a story of every remarkable woman that ever lived. This one line summarises everything the movie aims to portray. It is not about patriotism, not about ‘dushman-desh’ or not even about the IAF. It is just about an innocent girl aiming to soar high but put down by the society that leaves no stone unturned to say that she is not worth her dreams. But, who are they to say anyways? The Kargil girl disproves them in style. It is the story of every woman. Misogyny spares no woman. We all sail through it on a daily basis. It may be adrenaline charging to see women giving savage comebacks and dismantling patriarchy through powerful monologues on screen. But, honestly, we never do that on a regular basis. Sometimes yes. But, definitely not always. Most of the time we suck up and carry on with our work, believing our actions would speak up for itself. Gunjan Saxena is that kind. That doesn’t...
Post a Comment
Read more